Skip to content

Odyssey Mushroom Chocolate Bar - Midnight Mint vs Shroomiez Mushroom Chocolate Bar - Cookies & Cream

Updated March 2026

Two top chocolate bar products compared side by side.

Feature
Odyssey Mushroom Chocolate Bar - Midnight Mint

Legacy score: 8.8. Rating source, scale and date not recorded.

Shroomiez Mushroom Chocolate Bar - Cookies & Cream

Legacy score: 8. Rating source, scale and date not recorded.

Price
$9.99
$7.49
Price/Serving
$2.50
$1.87
Format
Chocolate Bar
Chocolate Bar
Key Mushrooms
Lion's Mane, Cordyceps
Reishi, Chaga, Turkey Tail
Mushroom Content
2500mg
350mg
COA Verified
✅ Yes
❌ No
Certifications
Organic, Vegan, Non-GMO
Non-GMO
Odyssey Mushroom Chocolate Bar - Midnight Mint

Odyssey Mushroom Chocolate Bar - Midnight Mint

Odyssey Elixir

Legacy score: 8.8. Rating source, scale and date not recorded.

No sourced customer rating recorded.

Top Rated
  • Highest mushroom dosage in a chocolate bar
  • Excellent mint chocolate flavor
  • Full COA available
  • Premium price point
  • Mint flavor not for everyone
Shroomiez Mushroom Chocolate Bar - Cookies & Cream

Shroomiez Mushroom Chocolate Bar - Cookies & Cream

Shroomiez

Legacy score: 8. Rating source, scale and date not recorded.

No sourced customer rating recorded.

Best Taste
  • Unique cookies & cream flavor
  • Triple immune mushroom blend
  • Approachable for beginners
  • Not COA verified
  • White chocolate is higher sugar

How They Compare: Ingredients

Odyssey Mushroom Chocolate Bar - Midnight Mint

Mushroom Blend
Lion's ManeCordyceps
Total Content

2500mg per serving

Certifications
OrganicVeganNon-GMOLab Tested

Shroomiez Mushroom Chocolate Bar - Cookies & Cream

Mushroom Blend
ReishiChagaTurkey Tail
Total Content

350mg per serving

Certifications
Non-GMO

How They Compare: Value

Odyssey Mushroom Chocolate Bar - Midnight Mint costs $9.99 ($2.50/serving for 4 servings), while Shroomiez Mushroom Chocolate Bar - Cookies & Cream is $7.49 ($1.87/serving for 4 servings). Shroomiez Mushroom Chocolate Bar - Cookies & Cream offers 25% better value per serving.

🏆 Our Verdict

This one's a toss-up. Both Odyssey Mushroom Chocolate Bar - Midnight Mint and Shroomiez Mushroom Chocolate Bar - Cookies & Cream are solid picks. Your choice depends on personal taste, budget, and goals.

Bottom line: Both are excellent choices. Pick the one whose flavor profile and brand vibe resonates with you.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Odyssey Mushroom Chocolate Bar - Midnight Mint or Shroomiez Mushroom Chocolate Bar - Cookies & Cream better?

Both are strong options. Odyssey Mushroom Chocolate Bar - Midnight Mint and Shroomiez Mushroom Chocolate Bar - Cookies & Cream each have unique strengths. Your choice depends on your priorities — ingredients, price, taste, and personal goals all matter.

What's the main difference between Odyssey Mushroom Chocolate Bar - Midnight Mint and Shroomiez Mushroom Chocolate Bar - Cookies & Cream?

The biggest difference is formulation. Odyssey Mushroom Chocolate Bar - Midnight Mint uses Lion's Mane, Cordyceps, while Shroomiez Mushroom Chocolate Bar - Cookies & Cream features Reishi, Chaga, Turkey Tail. They also differ in price, taste, and certifications.

Which is better value, Odyssey Mushroom Chocolate Bar - Midnight Mint or Shroomiez Mushroom Chocolate Bar - Cookies & Cream?

Shroomiez Mushroom Chocolate Bar - Cookies & Cream offers better value at $1.87/serving vs $2.50/serving for Odyssey Mushroom Chocolate Bar - Midnight Mint. That's 25% savings per serving.

Catalog product finder

Compare functional mushroom products.

Narrow a selection of non-psychoactive products by your preferences, then compare ingredients, formats, and listed prices.

  • 01 Choose your preferences
  • 02 Compare catalog products
  • 03 Read the product details
Find products to compare

⚖️ Compare Supplements

Four Sigmatic vs MUD\WTR MUD\WTR vs RYZE Everyday Dose vs Clevr Blends RYZE vs Everyday Dose View all comparisons →